A Personal Blog
Review: MSN Music Site
Microsoft recently “launched” (official launch later today, apparently) it’s MSN Music Store.
The obvious comparison is between this and the iTunes Application. Joe Wilcox already has a great take on this.
Primarily, I prefer MSN’s store for a couple of reasons. First, it’s web based. That means I can browse songs from anywhere, add them to my collection from anywhere and redownload songs as I need to from anywhere. That’s a good thing. A very good thing. Also, the store does not lock you into using Internet Explorer to use the more advanced features (music previews). You will need to have ActiveX installed (take that as you will) and running in Windows Media Player’s Zone (you may need to create it if you’re trying to lock ActiveX out from regular surfing). But, you can happily use Mozilla, FireFox or Opera if you so desire, as long as you install the ActiveX extensions for each of these.
The music selection seems fairly good. I looked for some “non mainstream” (in their genres) stuff in a variety of sections (jazz, christian music and world mainly) and found instances of everything I was looking for, even if I didn’t find the exact song.
The website is well designed, staying away from top-loading the page (like Apple’s sites do…).
The ads are non intrusive and, really, helped me out. While searching for songs I found several things that caught my eye in the ads. They’re even more “out of the way” than Google’s. Some people will complain that they are paying for the music so shouldn’t see ads. Whatever. They aren’t in the way and it’s not like you’re paying for the bandwidth you’re using while previewing songs. If all you have to do is ignore a few ads in order to listen to some songs, so be it.
Also, the Radio, TV and Movies sections are welcome additions. Being from Canada I’m not sure I can buy from the store yet (I still can’t from iTunes). Overall I’m glad this is here. If I ever get a Digital Music Player it probably won’t be an iPod (unless I get my free one). In which case my best option really is WMA format, so the MSN store could easily be the place to go.
I’m happy with this. If you prefer Apple, iTunes and your iPod this obviously isn’t the best option for you. If you’re looking for a new WMA store, give the new MSN one a shot. I know a couple of guys on the team and they are very happy with what they’ve put together and they should be. Well done to all.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Jeremy Wright on September 2, 2004 at 8:08 am, and is filed under General, IT Thoughts. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed. |
Comments are closed.
about 7 years ago
Honestly, I don’t hate it. I’d read all these cynical comments about how it was just going to be an iTunes ripoff (and it is understandably similar), but it’s really not bad.
That said, I don’t think I’ll use it, because I use iTunes (the software) to manage my music. Microsoft isn’t going to get the people who use iTunes; they’d have no real incentive to switch (at least not as long as the two stores are similar). But if you’re not tied to Apple in any significant way, this seems (at first glance) like a pretty good solution.
about 7 years ago
I work on the MSN Entertainment team – glad to see you like the site. Thanks for checking it out, and feel free to send us any feedback you have!
about 7 years ago
I’d just like one in europe so that I could buy some. :P
about 7 years ago
It sounds like you gave every excuse to like the site. And it doesn’t hurt to have a few friends who work on it.
I don’t think it looks anything like iTunes, though everyone is saying it’s a rip off of it. I do think the site is bland, which out much energy to move me around it. The search seems to only search by song. Doing a search on Queen, did not bring up the band but by song titles with Queen in them. But no Queen songs or even the band named Queen appeared.
For some reason, IE must use a different set of HTML character codes, since they use which show up as bullets in IE but as Capital Y umlat in Moz (which is the correct character). They should have used for bullets. This does not make or break the site in the least, but it is odd looking to say the least.
It’s still a new site, we’ll see how everything goes though I can’t say I will use.
about 7 years ago
good